OpenHistoricalMap

Deleted redundant boundary superrelation (already superseded by chronology relation); added chronology relation for San Marino as a place; moved wiki tags to chronology relations

Closed over 1 year ago by Minh Nguyen

Tags

• Comment from jeffmeyer about 1 year ago

  Removing the country-level wikitags from the component relations leaves the left nav / inspector w/no descriptive info. Is this what we want?

• Comment from Minh Nguyen about 1 year ago

  In this case, I was linking the chronology relation to https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q120752286, which is about the territorial evolution of San Marino. That item has no associated Wikipedia article, so the inspector wouldn’t show a snippet anyways.

  More generally, I think we should limit the wiki tags to the highest-order element when it exactly matches the Wikidata item. One practical reason is that the snippet won’t be tailored to the individual member.

  For example, the inspector lists a date range of 1860–1870 for https://www.openhistoricalmap.org/node/2104063828 based on its start_date and end_date tags, but the snippet immediately below it says “between 1859 and 1870”, referring to the entire chronology.

  I realize this is unsatisfying, but maybe what we need is a more convenient way to navigate a chronology relation, starting with https://github.com/OpenHistoricalMap/issues/issues/601

• Comment from Minh Nguyen about 1 year ago

  A clearer example: is https://www.openhistoricalmap.org/node/2104063830 from 1799 to 1809 or from 756 to 1870?

Log in to join the discussion