Changeset: 165662
train route
Closed by FK27
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (19369 de) |
---|---|
source | OHM |
Discussion
-
Comment from ManuelB701
I've changed it back to route=railway because it isn't a train route: route=train is a PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION route (one which usually is served by a mainline train) but not all railways are served by public transportation.
-
Comment from FK27
Thanks for your comment. Please read https://github.com/OpenHistoricalMap/issues/issues/1007 with care, especially the part written by @Rub21, as he is responsable for software development.
route=railway without start_date creates an ETERNAL railroad that appears on the map even when Charlemagne rode a horse.
-
Comment from ManuelB701
The problem with your change is that this is a hack (or as we OSMers call it, tagging for the data consumer) and will only lead to later issues thanks to the misrepresented data instead of fixing it straight up.
Think about it: Someone could create an OHM version of ÖPNKarte and users will notice that weird route which spans from Frankfurt to Wiesbaden. Sooner or later, someone will notice that this relation doesn't refer to any PT route but rather a railway relation which happen to be tagged as PT relation and will change it to route=railway (not to mention we're back to square run about an eternal route which didn't exist in the 18th century and earlier).
-
Comment from FK27
Whole OHM is a single hack. As for now, the 1825 map is free of railroads, and that's a good thing.
-
Comment from ManuelB701
Claiming that "OHM is a single hack" is still not a good excuse to falsify data.
After looking at both relations, I've realised that they represent the states in which the tracks go to Wiesbaden (before 1906 when the old station existed and past 1906 where the tracks follow the current relation).
In any case, what I just did was to apply a proper fix, to add a start_date for each relation (and also add a chronology relation because it is a major route which changed over time quite a lot alongside end_date for the older relation because that became invalid).
Relations (1)
Welcome to OpenHistoricalMap!
OpenHistoricalMap is an interactive map of the world throughout history, created by people like you and dedicated to the public domain.
OpenHistoricalMap is a charter project of OpenStreetMap U.S., a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization affiliated with the OpenStreetMap Foundation. Technical development is supported by GreenInfo Network and Development Seed.
https://www.openhistoricalmap.org/copyright | https://www.openhistoricalmap.org |
OpenHistoricalMap is dedicated to the public domain except where otherwise noted. |